Michael Deeg as Alfonse
Elizabeth Regen as Gina
Maddie Corman as Marilyn
Joe Lo Truglio as Dave
Kamal Ahmed as Umpire #3
Armin Amiri as Steakhouse Waiter
Anya Avaeva as Exotic Dancer
Todd Barry as Creepy Guy Down the Shore
Mary Birdsong as Rhonda
Charlene Biton as Layla (as Kristy Redford)
Jim Breuer as Football Guy
Jared Burke as Ed's Bar & Swill Player
Gino Cafarelli as Dakis
David Carney as Umpire #2
Alex Corrado as Ed
Albert DeGrasse as Ed's Bar & Swill Player
Nick DiPaolo as Cousin Mickey
Rich Duva as Ed's Bar & Swill Player
Bret Ernst as Corino Third Baseman
Tina Fey as Front Desk Girl
Jim Florentine as Crispino
Joseph R. Gannascoli as Giusuppe Primavera
Shane Geraghty as Softball Player
Keren Gilbert as Vicki Galliotta
Matthew Gumley as Tommy

Brigitte Hagerman as One of Dennis Mangenelli's girls
Hollie Harper as Tim's Wife
John Heinlein as Mangenelli 3rd baseman
Frank Hopf as Manganelli left center fielder
Lauren Hugnou as Hooker #1
Maria Javier as Hooker #2
Joanne Joseph as Dirt's Wife
Keisha as Michelle "Pitching Machine"
Tim Lajcik as Manganelli Outfielder
Jodi Lennon as Melissa
Mike Lisenco as Umpire #1 (as Michael Lisenco)
Louis Lombardi as Chief Gugliamino
Dana Lorge as Gina's Mom
Erik Martin as Manganelli Catcher
Steve Nuke as 2nd Base Man - Green Team
George Palermo as Mangenelli First Baseman
Rich Pecci as Bachleor Party Guy
Frank Pellegrino as Gina's Dad
Bill Scheft as Championship Game Ump
Christian Sebastiano as Manganelli 2nd Baseman
Francisco Sebastiano as Dave's Baby
Rosalinda Sebastiano as Marie
George Seminara as Shoot the Geek Barker
Daniel Tay as Max
Nathalie Walker as Hooker #3 (as Natalie Twaddle)